On this page
Preventive and corrective maintenance, defined
Preventive maintenance is planned servicing carried out on a schedule to stop equipment failing: cleaning AC coils before summer, descaling a water heater, tightening electrical connections. Corrective maintenance (often called reactive maintenance) is repair work done after something has failed or a fault has been found.
| Preventive | Corrective | |
|---|---|---|
| When the work happens | On a schedule you set | After a failure |
| Labour rates | Normal hours | Often out of hours, at a premium |
| Parts | Ordered in advance | Whatever is available today |
| Damage that follows | Usually avoided | Ceilings, floors, stock |
| Equipment life | Close to expected | Shorter |
| Year one cost | Higher, as the backlog is found | Looks lower |
Reactive maintenance looks cheaper because the cost arrives as a series of emergencies rather than a line in a budget. Emergencies are never cheaper than the same work done on a schedule. If you manage a building, this is how to put a number on it.
The five costs of running reactive
1. Emergency premium
Out-of-hours attendance, rushed parts, and whatever the first available contractor charges when you have no regular firm and no alternative. Every reactive repair carries this. Scheduled work does not.
2. Shortened asset life
This is the largest number and the least visible. Equipment run without maintenance does not fail once. It wears steadily, and it reaches the end of its life well before it should.
Model it: take your major assets and their expected service life, and estimate what fraction you lose to neglect. Apply that to the replacement cost. For a site with several large units, this one line usually dwarfs everything else in the comparison.
3. Damage that follows
The failure rarely stays contained. A blocked condensate drain becomes a ceiling. A leaking pipe becomes a floor. A failed cooling unit in a panel room becomes a control board. Count the repair you paid for, not the one you would have paid if someone had caught it early. Water damage also brings mould, and the US EPA's guide to mould and moisture is blunt that the key to mould control is controlling moisture, which is preventive work by another name.
4. Downtime
Hours not trading, production stopped, a cold store losing stock, tenants complaining. For most commercial sites this is the number that persuades the finance director, and it is usually easy to estimate because you already know what an hour is worth.
5. Management time
Someone in your organisation spends hours on every unplanned failure: finding a contractor, approving spend, arranging access, chasing completion. Multiply that by the number of incidents a year. It is rarely small.
Building the comparison
Take your last two years of maintenance spend and sort every invoice into planned or unplanned. Most sites running reactively find the split is heavily unplanned, and that the unplanned side is far larger than anyone assumed.
Then add the four costs above that never appeared as an invoice. That total is your real reactive cost.
Against it, set the cost of a planned regime: scheduled visits, consumables, and the remedial work the reports will generate. Include the remedial line in full. A preventive programme finds things, and finding things costs money in year one. Whether you buy that regime as a contract or visit by visit is a separate question, covered in AMC vs pay per call.
Why year one looks worse
This part catches people out, so we will say it plainly.
A preventive programme's first year usually costs more than the reactive year before it, because the first survey turns up a backlog nobody knew about. The programme is working as intended. Those items existed before; they were simply invisible.
The saving appears from year two, and it builds each year after.
Where preventive does not pay
There are three exceptions.
Assets already at the end of their life. Servicing a failing compressor is spending money to delay a decision. Replace it and start preventive work on the new one.
Very small or simple sites. A single-unit office needs an annual service, not a programme. If its one unit stops cooling, start with our guide to AC not cooling.
Where nobody will act on the reports. A programme producing recommendations that are never funded is an expensive filing exercise. If the budget to act does not exist, say so and prioritise hard instead.
The Al Ain adjustment
Inland sites need a different schedule from the coastal templates most FM specifications are built on. Al Ain runs several degrees hotter, with inland highs of 38 to 44°C against 35 to 41°C on the coast and 48°C on record, and sandstorms come and go through the hot months. Filter and condenser intervals here are shorter than a coastal specification assumes. Humidity, meanwhile, falls to around 21% in May, so drain pan and biological treatment needs are lower. Copy a Dubai schedule and you get both ends wrong.
See how we build one for preventive maintenance in Al Ain, or request a free quote after a site survey.
Related: facility management checklist for warehouses · does a contract save you money?